Could You Be Better Off Paying Down Your Debt Slowly?

by Miranda Marquit · 14 comments

in debt

There’s a lot to be said for paying off your debt and living debt free. After all, it’s tempting to try to pay it off as quickly as possible whenever you look at that balance. This impulse is often encouraged by stories of consumers who made heroic efforts to pay down debt in a short amount of time.

But should you really work hard to pay off all of your debt right now?

It’s true that you can make big sacrifices, look for extra income, and pay off your debt in record time. But is it always the best route? And what happens when you are done paying off the debt. Will you stay debt free?

While you can definitely be successful taking an aggressive approach to debt reduction, it’s also important to consider whether it’s the best approach for your situation. Is it possible that you might be better off overall by taking it a little slower?

Paying Down Debt and Extreme Dieting

My weight used to yo-yo (but continue to move ever-higher) because I’d tackle those 10 or 15 pounds aggressively to reach a desired target. I’d spend six to eight weeks depriving myself and exercising more than usual. Once I hit that target, I’d slowly return to old habits. That’s because of the dramatic changes in my eating and exercise habits were unsustainable.

The same might be true of your finances. You can deprive yourself of everything you like to spend money on for a short period of time, but are you really tackling the root of the problem? My cyclical weight gain wasn’t my problem — it was a symptom of my lack of good habits. You might fall into the same trap when you pay down debt very quickly.

Are you really changing your habits, or going through temporary pain to hit a goal? The Bankruptcy Data Project at Harvard found that about one-third of those who file for bankruptcy wind up in the same place later. This can also happen when you pay off debt very quickly without truly changing your approach.

Smaller Changes Can Mean More Sustainable Results

Once I stopped crash dieting, I started making smaller, more sustainable changes. It took longer to reach my goal weight, but it was easier to maintain that weight once I reached it. Incremental changes to my nutrition and exercise habits stuck. The same approach can work when it comes to debt. Focus on changing your money habits in ways that you can maintain for the long haul. Then tackle your debt.

Another consideration is the need to be ready for the unexpected. When my then-husband and I were first married, we tried demolishing our debt in one big payment, draining our savings. Unfortunately, a rash of unexpected repairs and similar expenses cropped up almost immediately after making that payment. And since we didn’t have any savings because we used the funds to pay off our debt, we had to turn to credit cards. In no time, we were right back where we started.

Don’t forget to shore up your finances even as you pay down debt. You might pay more interest right now, but you could save in the long run if you can manage matters so that you don’t wind up back in debt.

The type of debt you carry should dictate whether you should pay it off as soon as possible too.

High Interest Consumer Debt vs. Other Debt

Many of us routinely lump all debt together and call it “bad.” And while there is an argument that there’s no such thing as good debt, the truth is that some debt is worse than other debt.

High interest consumer debt is the worst type of debt. This is money owed on things that we consume — things that don’t retain value and don’t provide the hope of income or some type of solid return later. Not only do you pay for something that won’t have the same value a year from now (or that might be totally gone a year from now), but you also pay a high rate of interest on it.

Credit cards are a good example of this since credit card debt often (but not always) results from purchases made for consumer items like clothes and electronics. High interest consumer debt doesn’t offer you the chance to build assets, and you almost definitely won’t receive any sort of return; you’ll just be paying high interest charges into someone else’s pocket.

Other types of debt aren’t quite so terrible. While student loan debt can keep you down, it isn’t the worst thing out there. In fact, when used carefully and judiciously, student loans can help you get the education and skills you need to boost your earning power over time. Student loans often come with lower interest rates than consumer loans, which means you pay less for the privilege of borrowing.

And who could forget about mortgages? With rates at historic lows, there’s a case to be made for using the funds to invest for the long term. The same goes for using business loans to fund a venture. You can see a return if you play your cards right, but you have to be careful not to get carried away to the point that your low interest debt turns into a burden, rather than a benefit.

Choosing to Put Off Paying a Debt

Not too long ago, my mom asked me why I wasn’t putting as much as I possibly could toward my student loan debt. My answer was this: the fixed interest rate on my student loans is below 2%. I’ve been able to manage better returns than that on my investments. My annualized returns on my conservative retirement account have even beat that — recession and all.

From my small P2P loan portfolio to my taxable account to my Roth IRA, my money is better used earning an annualized return of 5.5% to 7% (depending on the account) than it is paying down a debt that isn’t even costing me 2%.

At least that’s my opinion.

At some point, especially if my income is much higher that a bit of excess return won’t benefit me as much, I might consider tackling the student loan debt a little more aggressively. But for now, it doesn’t make a lot of sense to me.

Some debts are a little more urgent than others. You’re probably not going to earn 18.99% on your investments, so paying down credit card debt makes sense. But if you have low interest, non-consumer debt, you might think twice before retiring it, especially if you might instead pay down your low interest debt only to turn to high interest ones in a pinch.

What do you think? Should all debt be paid off immediately? Or are some debts worth waiting on?

Money Saving Tip: An incredibly effective way to save more is to reduce your monthly Internet and TV costs. Click here for the current Verizon FiOS promotion codes and promos to see if you can save more money every month from now on.

{ read the comments below or add one }

  • Chris says:

    I have a question about what I should do. I have roughly $10,000 in student loan debt and that’s it. I am currently a sophomore in college. I recently got a large scholarship so I won’t have to take out student loans ever again. I just got a job where I make a about $2000 a month and have about $1000 in bills every month. My question is should I just keep stacking this overhead money (and invest, of course) or should I just grind over the course of the next year or so and graduate with no debt (something that is very rare in America). Just need some guidance here thanks.

    • David @ says:

      I don’t think there’s a “right” answer here, Chris. What’s more profitable will depend on how the market does in the next few years. However, being debt free is pretty special. Since your loan is not huge and payable within a short period of time, I would, if I were you, take a year or so and pay it off first before I invest. I can always aggressively invest after this.

      The plan changes if you have access to 401ks and Roth IRAs though. If you do, then I will fill up those buckets to the limit if you can first because you are young and you don’t want to miss out on decades of compound growth.

      So this is what I will do. First, build up the emergency fund while paying all the monthly dues. Then, once I have a solid emergency fund, I will put money into my tax advantaged accounts like 401ks and Roth IRAs. Then I will pay off my student loan. Finally, once the student loan is eliminated, then I will invest.

  • Gale L. says:

    Wonderful! I appreciate this article, and I think that paying down debt slowly is key. If you can survive and invest in things that will bring in even more income then the debt isn’t that bad.



    • David @ says:

      If you plan to invest with money you borrow, then staying the course will be very important for you because market values are volatile.

      Take the long view!

  • Beau W. says:

    It’s an interesting topic and you make a good point. I was paying off my debt as much as I could every payday and I made a great deal of progress but I had to take a step back because I was not putting money in my IRA or my savings account. It was all going towards my debt. I slowed down and got back to investing and building my savings as much as possible. I’m glad I made the decision on slowing down. Debt can wait but investing in my future doesn’t wait. Great article.

    • David @ says:

      Good move Beau. I know it can be hard to shift focus sometimes. I’ve been paying off debt in the past few months with new money and it’s addicting to see that balance go down. I should follow your lead and start plowing some of the new funds back into my investment portfolio.

  • AthenaC says:

    As I’ve gotten older, I’ve thought of debt not as “bad” but as “less than optimal.” As in – all things being equal, would you rather have debt or have no debt? We’d rather have no debt, of course!

    But that’s not the world we live in. Unless you can pay in cash for your house, your education, a safe car large enough to transport multiple children, etc. – debt is simply a tool, and you have to make the right decisions to use it wisely.

    I am better off today because I took student loans, because I took a mortgage and bought a house, because I took a car loan when my previous car met an untimely demise. I’m better off because I used credit cards to bridge the gap between jobs, while moving, and during other transitional times.

    Debt can be a great tool, but like any tool, YOU have to be in control.

    • David @ says:

      Thanks for sharing how you’ve used credit to your benefit Athena. Credit can destroy lives but it could also be used to get further ahead. Use it wisely or else it’ll bite you in the future.

  • Matt says:

    I’ve always had the “pay off debt ASAP” mindset but the article makes some good points. I especially like the point that it doesn’t make sense to pay off debt quickly if you don’t address the root problem and you end up back into debt. Though, at the end of the day, I still lean towards being debt free even if it’s only 2 percent interest.

  • Mike Monfredi says:

    Thanks for the post and for your insight. Shedding light on these topics is huge and great for all parties.

    I would comment that success in weight loss or in eliminating debt is determined at the onset. If you are able to determine that this is a choice you ARE making and that you will succeed at any cost, the how becomes ancillary.

    I believe that everyone’s most effective plan is unique to the individual and the circumstances. Extreme, slow, or moderate – whatever gets the job done for you.


  • Aaron says:

    This is an interesting topic. I did the same thing – paid off my debt pretty slowly (over the course of 5 years). And, it worked for me as I personally haven’t taken on any more debt that I had previously (save for a home). There is something about having to make sacrificial decisions and “feeling the pain” of debt and poor decisions that sticks with a person.

    • David @ says:

      Congratulations on being debt free! Now that the weight is off your shoulders, you can concentrate your efforts on building wealth!

  • Lloyd says:

    Tackle the root cause, not the effect/symptom, in the this case, cause being money habits (overspending, impulse buying etc) and not how fast you pay off debt. Great article filled with tons of lessons.

Leave a Comment